How to Talk to Your Teen About PSAT Scores Without Adding Pressure

When PSAT scores come out, ask your teen what they want to know before opening the report together. They might want to understand one section, talk about a disappointing number, or leave the conversation for later. 

Once you know which conversation they want to have, you can use the report to pick a practical next step and give the score the amount of attention it deserves.

That first question is especially useful when friends are already comparing numbers. A parent might see the result as a chance to talk about college. A sophomore might be wondering what to say at lunch tomorrow. 

Both conversations can happen. Start with the one your teen is having right now.

Let your teen decide when to look

Pick a time when neither of you has to rush. If the results show up on their phone during the school day, try, “Want me to sit with you when you look at it, or would you rather have some time first?” 

Give them a few minutes to settle in after school. A quick check while someone is walking out the door can easily turn into a half-finished conversation that hangs over the evening.

Your teen may look at the report on their own and bring you one confusing detail later. They can also decide who else gets to hear their score, including siblings or relatives who are curious about how they did.

Where to find the score report

If access is the issue, Scholar’s Hub has a guide to finding PSAT scores. College Board says students can also ask their school for their report. Eligible students who provided their mobile number during in-school testing can use the BigFuture School app, and students aged 13 or older with a personal College Board account can access score information online.

If the report hasn’t appeared when you expect it, the school’s testing staff can help check when scores are due. Offer to help your teen find the right person to ask, then let them decide who will send the message.

Read the report in the right order

First, check the name of the test at the top. PSAT 10 and PSAT/NMSQT are separate assessments in the SAT Suite. College Board keeps both sets of PSAT scores out of the score reports it sends to colleges. The PSAT/NMSQT can serve as an entry point to the National Merit Scholarship Program for students who meet the program’s entry requirements. If your teen has a scholarship question, check the official requirements for their particular test and school year.

How to choose a skill to practice

Next, look at the Reading, Writing, and Math sections. College Board’s score guide explains how the report indicates skill areas and shows how a student’s performance compares with a reference group. 

If your teen zeroes in on a percentile, read the label beside it. A percentile describes the position of the score within that comparison group. For a decision about what to practice, the skill breakdown may give you a clearer starting point.

For example, a student who is comfortable with algebra might see room to work on interpreting data. That is a question they can take to a teacher. 

Ask if a few practice questions would help them understand the kinds of problems they missed. Once you have one question worth pursuing, you can close the report.

Give a disappointing score room to land

Your teen might say, “I thought I did better.” Ask which part surprised them. They might say the clock kept pulling their attention, they lost their place when reading, or they expected the math questions to look like their classwork. 

Listen through the answer before suggesting a solution. What they noticed during the test can help you decide what kind of support to offer afterward.

Give them time to finish telling you about the test. Friends may be posting scores or asking what everyone got. Offer a line your teen can make their own. “I’m keeping mine private” works in a group chat, too. A teen who is proud of the result may simply want you to be pleased with them. Give that moment some space before talking about the next test.

How to reopen a tense conversation

If the conversation started badly, revisit it briefly. “I jumped into planning before I asked how you felt about it. What would be helpful from me?” 

The American Academy of Pediatrics advises parents who suspect academic pressure is contributing to anxiety to express pride and support. One way to do that is to name something specific you noticed, such as how your teen asked their teacher for help with a type of problem they found confusing.

Pick a small next step together

Ask what your teen wants from the report. A tenth grader who wants to get more comfortable with timed questions might choose a short set of practice problems and review where time went. 

Another student might take the report to an English teacher and ask for help with one reading skill. If your teen is still deciding whether to take the SAT, a school counselor can help them check which tests matter for the routes they are considering and when those decisions come up.

Fit the next step into a week your teen already has. Suppose they get home late on Tuesdays and have a project due Friday. A ten-minute look at practice questions over the weekend is something you can agree on without reorganizing the whole week. 

Put it on the calendar if they want a reminder. Agree on what will count as done, such as bringing one question to class on Monday.

Families sometimes finish reading the report and immediately start shopping for tutoring. Give your teen a chance to describe what kind of help they’d actually use. They might be willing to stay after school once to work through a few questions with a teacher.

If a teacher suggests targeted practice, ask which skill to work on and how the student can tell whether they understand it better. That conversation can help you decide if you need a longer plan.

Set a separate time to talk about college

If the report prompts a bigger conversation about college, separate it on the calendar. A teen may want to compare an apprenticeship with a two-year program or look at the application requirements of a few colleges. 

Give that conversation a day of its own and let your teen bring a question they actually care about. That way, the family can pay attention to applications, costs, and deadlines without trying to settle them all while the score report is on the screen.

Notice when stress is spilling into everyday life

Check in over time if worry about school keeps showing up beyond score day. The National Institute of Mental Health suggests seeking help when a young person’s emotions or behavior persist, cause significant distress, or interfere with life at school, at home, or with friends. 

A teen might repeatedly stay awake worrying about grades, start missing classes on test days, or give up things they usually enjoy because they feel they always need to study. If you notice a pattern, try naming what you see in plain language and asking how it feels from their side.

Who can help with ongoing school stress?

You could say, “I’ve noticed you’ve been up late worrying about school several nights this week. How has the week felt to you?” That gives your teen something specific to respond to. You can offer to help talk with a school counselor or pediatrician. 

Bring a few recent examples and explain how long the changes have been happening. It helps the person you speak with understand what your teen and family are dealing with across an ordinary school week.

If a clinician recommends looking at additional care, families in Arizona can review Artemis Adolescent Healing Center’s teen mental health treatment options. Its program page explains how assessment helps determine the appropriate level of care for adolescents ages 12 to 17.

Leave the conversation open

A few days later, pick up where you left off. Ask what they learned if they decided to practice one skill or took a question to a teacher. 

For a conversation you postponed, offer another time and give your teen a say in when you return to it.

The next time a score comes home, your teen should know what to expect from you. They can share good news, ask a question, or talk about something that felt hard. 

You can help them make sense of the information and decide what they want to do with it.

References

American Academy of Pediatrics. (2024, September 24). Help your child manage anxiety: Tips for home & school. HealthyChildren.org. https://www.healthychildren.org/English/family-life/family-dynamics/Pages/help-your-child-manage-fears-and-anxieties.aspx

College Board. (n.d.-a). If my child takes the PSAT/NMSQT, will colleges get their scores? https://satsuite.collegeboard.org/help-center/if-my-child-takes-psatnmsqt-will-colleges-get-their-scores

College Board. (n.d.-b). What do my SAT Suite scores mean? https://satsuite.collegeboard.org/scores/what-scores-mean

College Board. (n.d.-c). Where can my child get their PSAT/NMSQT, PSAT 10, or PSAT 8/9 scores? BigFuture. https://bigfuture.collegeboard.org/help-center/where-can-my-child-get-their-psatnmsqt-psat-10-or-psat-89-scores

College Board. (n.d.-d). Who sees my child’s PSAT 10 scores? https://satsuite.collegeboard.org/help-center/who-sees-my-childs-psat-10-scores

National Institute of Mental Health. (2024). Children and mental health: Is this just a stage? https://www.nimh.nih.gov/health/publications/children-and-mental-health

National Merit Scholarship Corporation. (n.d.). Entry requirements. https://www.nationalmerit.org/s/1758/interior.aspx?gid=2&pgid=1876&sid=1758